McGahee@Chicago or Caddy@NO?!

[Monty'sCircus]

:confused:
A must win week for me...McGahee has the most yrds of any back right now, but is going against chicago. Caddy has been horrible with the play of the oline. Right now I have caddillac in the line up to start this week, but Im seriously considering benching him, because I doubt NO will respect the passing game.
Kevin Jones is the other back and I am going to start him.
Thoughts please...

[SimeonSack]

McGahee. Cadillac has been doing very badly, and Grad as QB won't be any help to him.

[RJS147]

I would start both of them over Kevin Jones.

[Monty'sCircus]

Jones is @ minn though and he hit paydirt 2x last week. Im in a league that doesnt take away for fumbles though so Im quite happy with that.

[ATL-owns-TB]

I would start both of them over Kevin Jones.
I agree.

[Monty'sCircus]

I was already torn between 2 backs and now you have me uneasy about all 3...erk...Jones was riding the pine the 1st 2 games, and had to start him due to caddy's performance...oh fey

[Crocaneers]

Drop Caddie and look in FA wire ..

[Monty'sCircus]

Drop Caddie and look in FA wire ..
caddy is still on the cant cut list...but he has to come around sometime this season.

[Cardiac Kids]

McGahee. Cadillac has been doing very badly, and Grad as QB won't be any help to him.

That's just ignorant. We all know Gruden is going to get the running game going, he has to take pressure off of Gradkowski. Caddilac knows he better get something going if he wants to win. He got a small taste of it last week and i can guarantee you he wants more of it. The more production he gets the more Bruce will benefit.

You guys don't see, before, nobody had to worry about Chris, all they had to do was practice putting their arms up, they knew he wasn't going anywhere, and could spend most of the week watching film and practicing against our other weapons. Now we are down to Bruce, who nobody has tape on, sort of like Caddy last year. They have to prepare for him and that means less preparation on Caddy. Expect Caddy to have a much improved week, possibly his first 100 yd. game. I'm not guaranteeing us a win. Just an improved effort from our offensive weapons because of lack of preparation by the Saints.

McGahee is the NFL leader. but he's avg. less than 100 yds a game and with only one TD he's starting to pan out. Caddy has the same amount of TD's.

[PirateAttack]

I can't believe people think that McGahee is worth starting vs the best D in the league. Don't forget, the Bills play @ Chicago.

Start Jones and Caddy. Caddy has the better matchup despite not producing very much this season. If anything the disrespect for the passing game vs NO might open up the run game if we have any success through the air.

Crazier things have happened. I'de sit McGahee this week. Did anyone else watch the Seahawks game on Sunday Night!? T. Harris is a beast and that Chicago D tore apart one of the best OL's in football.

[Monty'sCircus]

Will now that walker is out, I think I am going to let caddy ride the pine.

[PirateAttack]

Will now that walker is out, I think I am going to let caddy ride the pine.
:confused: Um.. care to explain? lol..

[SimeonSack]

That's just ignorant. We all know Gruden is going to get the running game going, he has to take pressure off of Gradkowski. Caddilac knows he better get something going if he wants to win. He got a small taste of it last week and i can guarantee you he wants more of it. The more production he gets the more Bruce will benefit.

You guys don't see, before, nobody had to worry about Chris, all they had to do was practice putting their arms up, they knew he wasn't going anywhere, and could spend most of the week watching film and practicing against our other weapons. Now we are down to Bruce, who nobody has tape on, sort of like Caddy last year. They have to prepare for him and that means less preparation on Caddy. Expect Caddy to have a much improved week, possibly his first 100 yd. game. I'm not guaranteeing us a win. Just an improved effort from our offensive weapons because of lack of preparation by the Saints.

McGahee is the NFL leader. but he's avg. less than 100 yds a game and with only one TD he's starting to pan out. Caddy has the same amount of TD's.

So your logic is that no one worried about Simms, but they're going to be sweating it out when his backup comes into the game, a 6th round rookie pick? According to that logic we should be putting in rookies all the time so the other team won't know how to handle us. A new QB every year so no one knows what to do against us. My guess is that they won't be too worried about him, even if they don't have film on him.

As far as Cadillac getting motivated, McGahee won't be motivated? Since when does Cadillac care more about football than McGahee?

My only doubt about McGahee is the matchup, Chicago is a monster defense. But I don't trust Cadillac to have a big game since he hasn't done it yet and Grad won't help his game at all. I'd maybe look to put a 3rd WR in if that's an option for you, or maybe even check if there are any good RBs in the FA market.

[Monty'sCircus]

:confused: Um.. care to explain? lol..
Just more fuel to the fire. Walker hasnt been absolutely terrible this yr, and with a rookie tackle in the game the online can only play that much worse.

[PirateAttack]

Sorry, that was before I had heard about K. Walker being out for the season. I thought you were talking about Javon Walker or something, lol.

[Fast Lane]

McGahee. Cadillac has been doing very badly, and Grad as QB won't be any help to him.


agreed

[Fast Lane]

I would start both of them over Kevin Jones.


uh, no way. Jones, McGahee, Caddy, in that order.