Trade Opinion

[M_Easy]

Should I trade Derek Anderson for Larry Fitzgerald? If I did Garcia would be my starter. It's a 2 RB, 2 WR, and 1 RB/WR league. Here's my roster:

D. Anderson
J. Garcia

B. Westbrook
E. James
S. Young
K. Smith
M. Pittman

R. Wayne
B. Edwards
D. Stallworth
I. Hilliard
J. Walker

H. Miller

A. Vinatieri

Bucs
Bills (only for this week)

This trade wouldn't take affect until Mon. I think Garcia should be efficient enough to get me through the season, but I wanted to grab a couple outside opinions. Playoffs start Week 14.

Thanks...

[BlackHawk]

Why??? You're set at WR...and Garcia is NOT a viable fantasy QB...

[M_Easy]

My flex positions not set though. Stallworth and Hilliard aren't consistent. Young and Smith are both dependent on other players not starting. And, Pittman and Walker are not guaranteed to perform when they come back (when ever that may be).

While Anderson has put up the 3rd most points at QB in my league (185) Garcia has been "viable" with 142 points (8th in my league).

Garcia has Atl, Was, NO, Hou, Atl, and SF. Anderson has Bal, Hou, Ari, NYJ, Buf, Cincy.

If you wouldn't dump Anderson, what would you counter with? Garcia and Pittman or Smith?

[M_Easy]

My deadline is next week; does anyone else have any thoughts on this trade?

[Buccs99]

do it.

[Crocaneers]

do it.

.... and miss the playoffs.

[Pewter Pride]

My deadline is next week; does anyone else have any thoughts on this trade?
Stay away from it.

Derek Anderson has been an absolute stud this year, throwing 2-3 TD games week in and week out (Garcia has only thrown two scores in a game 3 times this year). He throws more INTs than average, but with the way he puts up points, it really negates that completely. I wish I had claimed him off waivers when I had the chance.

You say your flex position isn't locked in, well that's true for now. But all signs indicate that Selvin Young will take over the starting role in Denver. If it isn't Travis Henry's injuries, it's his impending suspension. Be patient and try to wait it out, it should be worth it.

If you have your heart set on getting Fitzgerald, your best bet would be to counter with Garcia and Stallworth. If that's too much for you to give up, then you're SOL. I don't see anyone trading for both Garcia (Bucs) and Pittman (Bucs) considering our team's offensive production this year. I don't bring up Garcia for Hilliard (1 touchdown on the season) or Walker (bum knee) for the sake of fairness. I don't even know who K. Smith is, so I assume he has zero trade value. Are you talking about Kolby Smith of the Chiefs? Guy who has 28 rushing yards on the season and no touchdowns? Waste of a roster spot if that's who you're referring to.

Just my opinion.