I want to punch McShay in the face

[dawgland]

How the hell, in a matter of like two days, do you go from saying "Mario Manningham's stock has slipped big time because of his 4.6" to saying "the scouting combine is only weighs about 10% in terms of a players stock, and that most of it goes by watching tapes"


seriously dude, you flip more than John Kerry. just get off my TV

[UMiamiBucFan]

You're right, McShay should just stick to his website work where he isn't put on the spot for an opinion.

He also keeps flip flopping Mendenhall and McFadden on who the better running back is. Scouts, Inc has had McFadden listed as the #1 running back for awhile now. When Mayock started listing Mendenhall as the #1 RB, McShay said he thought Mendenhall was the better running back until McFadden ran a 4.3. All the while Scouts Inc continues to list McFadden as #1.

[TampaBay012286]

How the hell, in a matter of like two days, do you go from saying "Mario Manningham's stock has slipped big time because of his 4.6" to saying "the scouting combine is only weighs about 10% in terms of a players stock, and that most of it goes by watching tapes"


seriously dude, you flip more than John Kerry. just get off my TV

honestly, i could give more reliable analysis than him :p

mike mayock isnt exactly the brightest guy either :p

[dawgland]

stupid mel kiper wanna be

[TampaBay012286]

stupid mel kiper wanna be

he has had his flaws lately too

[dawgland]

he has had his flaws lately too

kiper is generally right, as long as you don't listen to him till about 2 weeks before the draft.

[Chebington]

he has had his flaws lately too

Kiper has his flaws alot.

[buxter]

What?

A face punching thread and no Pete Pierson sighting?