good trade?

[ATL-owns-TB]

lol, im already in a yahoo league, 12 teams and the rosters are

1 qb
3 wrs
2 rbs
1 te
1 wr/rb.

starters are listed 1st:
Qbs: Carson palmer/ Steve McNair
Rb: Priest holmes, warrick dunn, Michael bennett/ and thomas jones
wr: Chad johnson, Anquan boldin, Mike Clayton/ Brandon stokely, Brandon Llyod, and justin McCareins
Te: Tony G. / Freddie jones

im a made a trade to another player offering bennet and stokley for rudi johnson. he countered with an offer. rudi johnson and reche caldwell for warrick dunn and stokley? should i take it?

[Bucs29]

I wouldn't.

[Leeroy]

In a heartbeat. Rudi Johnson is a far superior fantasy back to Warrick Dunn and Reche Caldwell was on his way to a breakout season last year. The difference between Johnson and Dunn should be much greater than the difference between Stokley and Caldwell. I'd take that trade and make fun of the guy for offering it afterwards.

[Ballin_Since_76]

yup! stockley had a good year last year but caldwell is projected as the number one on the chargers and showed some good stuff b4 he got injured. with dunn splitting the running game 3 ways, rudi looks a lot better than him too. go for it...

[Ballin_Since_76]

also michael bennet and thomas jones are now backups on their teams...

[ATL-owns-TB]

well i picked up jones because, lol, he is the only rb that is partly a starter available. But Bennett is still the projected starter at this point. Onterrio Smith is gone for the season, so he should put up some tds.

[Ballin_Since_76]

well i picked up jones because, lol, he is the only rb that is partly a starter available. But Bennett is still the projected starter at this point. Onterrio Smith is gone for the season, so he should put up some tds.

ya but u always run the risk of him getting hurt. they still mewelde morre who was productive last year and picked up fason in the second round i believe.